
On October 15, Dr. Stanley Nattel chaired his final CJC Symposium, “Gene-Based Molecular Therapies for Cardiovascular Disease: The Future Is Now.” Pictured, from left to right: Dr. Roger Hajjar, Dr. Robert Hegele, Dr. Jason Roberts, Dr. Nattel, and Dr. Gavin Oudit.
Retiring Editor-in-Chief reflects on 17 years at helm of Canadian Journal of Cardiology
When Dr. Stanley Nattel, an esteemed cardiologist and researcher, became Editor-in-Chief of Canadian Journal of Cardiology (CJC) in 2010, he approached the role with three primary goals in mind: Grow the journal’s reputation, increase its impact factor, and provide opportunities for the academic development of Canadian cardiovascular trainees, practitioners and scientists.
“I was hoping the journal would become a well-respected and desirable place for the publication of articles about cardiovascular medicine from Canada and around the world,” Dr. Nattel says.
During a remarkable era of leadership, he has achieved his goals, and then some.
As Dr. Nattel prepares to hand off to the next Editor-in-Chief at the end of the year, he reflects on his 17-year tenure, and considers the future.
“It has been an incredible opportunity to develop something that I think is of great value,” says Dr. Nattel, Professor of Medicine and Paul-David Chair in Cardiovascular Electrophysiology at the Université de Montréal. “And a wonderful experience to work with outstanding scientists and clinicians.”
Growth in a changing landscape
Undeniably, the job of Editor-in-Chief has grown significantly under his leadership.
Submissions to CJC have swelled from 400 a year in 2010 to about 3,500. Its Impact Factor has more than tripled to a five-year average of close to 6, in league with other highly respected international peer-reviewed journals.
As only the third Editor-in-Chief in 40 years, Dr. Nattel took the reins from Dr. Eldon Smith, a preeminent Canadian academic, leader and builder, who laid the groundwork to make CJC a serious journal and the Canadian Cardiovascular Society’s (CCS) official publication. Dr. Smith oversaw CJC’s inclusion in the Science Citation index, which establishes the widely used Impact Factor metric.
When Dr. Nattel moved into the editor’s chair, CJC’s impact factor was 1.3, which is modest for biomedical sciences.
To increase the journal’s profile and punch, Dr. Nattel bolstered CJC’s editorial board with established and promising international experts, involved a talented team of Canadian medical scientists as Associate Editors and promoted the development of special issues focused on important and rapidly-developing topics in the field.
Each special issue (there are four to six a year) gets mapped out at least a year in advance, and involves an active group of Guest Editors – all outstanding clinical and/or basic scientists. They brainstorm topics and themes and help identify potential content and authors.
“It requires significant effort and constitutes an important achievement to produce that many special issues each year,” says Dr. Nattel, who is also Director of the Electrophysiology Research Program at the Montreal Heart Institute. “We get articles from individuals who are truly experts in their field and might not otherwise submit spontaneously to CJC. We make a mark in areas that are rapidly developing and important.”
Special issues deliver valuable content, are widely cited, and contribute to the journal’s Impact Factor.
On top of these efforts, Dr. Nattel has overseen the creation of cardiovascular training programs, attracting widespread Canadian and global involvement.
“We’ve had some outstanding Canadian and international trainees who have begun as Trainee Members of the Editorial Board, some have advanced to become Trainee Assistant Editors, who handle manuscripts like a full Associate Editor, and several have even advanced to become full Associate Editors.”
Another program has provided extensive opportunities for trainees to write and publish a mentored scientific paper in CJC, which for many is their first publication in the scientific literature. “So that’s really been very successful.”
Balancing Canadian and international interests
Part of the juggling act of being CJC’s Editor-in-Chief is the need to serve Canadian clinicians and researchers, while attracting high-impact submissions from around the world.
“More than 80% of CJC submissions are now from outside of Canada, and over 80% of our readership is from outside Canada,” Dr. Nattel says. “That’s largely due to the global respect for the journal has acquired.”
To address the challenge of tending to these two audiences, Dr. Nattel created a new category of CJC papers focused on training and practice that are relevant to Canadian researchers and clinicians.
These features are limited to 1,500 words, with no more than five references and two display items. Articles fall into three categories: Contemporary Issues in Cardiology Practice; Health Policy and Promotion; and Training in Cardiovascular Medicine and Research.
New economic realities, digital transformation and the advent of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
While Editor-in-Chief, Dr. Nattel faced a sea change in the publishing world that created new economic realities.
Before the widespread use of electronic media, scientific and medical journals were largely paper-based and supported through print advertising. As external advertising dried up, journals moved to open-access publishing supported through publication fees.
This shift meant broadening the footprint of the CJC family to include two open-access peer-reviewed journals, CJC Open and CJC Pediatric and Congenital Heart Disease (CJCPC).
“If we hadn’t started the open-access journals, CJC would have difficulty maintaining itself financially. As it is, the family of journals is doing well,” he says.
Dr. Nattel meets regularly with Dr. Michelle Graham, Editor-in-Chief of CJC Open and Dr. Kevin Harris, Editor-in-Chief of CJCPC. They work together and share a common editorial support team. Dr. Nattel describes CJC as the linchpin because it receives the largest number of submissions, many more than it can publish. This allows for high-quality and relevant articles that can’t be accommodated in CJC to be offered transfer to one of the open-access journals, which many accept.
The open-access journals each have their niches, and collaboration among the three editors ensures the health and quality of the CJC family of journals, and that articles find their appropriate home and audience.
Submissions that aren’t necessarily novel enough for the CJC’s limited publication capacity and international audience, but are nevertheless meritorious, and those that are of significant interest to a Canadian readership can be offered transfer to CJC Open, for example. Similar ones with a specific focus on pediatric and/or congenital heart disease are directed to CJCPC.
On top of the move to open access, the culture of scientific publishing has changed dramatically in recent years due to the evolving use of AI. Dr. Nattel sees more papers submitted to the journal that have been written with AI.
While Dr. Nattel believes it’s acceptable for foreign-language speakers to use AI to brush up grammar and syntax, an AI-generated article simply doesn’t pass muster. “There is a style of article that I can sometimes recognize,” he says. “The wording, the structure… it’s a big issue.”
Another outcome of the age of AI is a surge in letters to the editor. “We used to get the occasional letter to the editor. Within the last year, we’ve had an explosion of letters to the editor that all have the same structure and format and approach, and it’s very clear that people were submitting letters that were generated by AI, possibly to get their name in a reputable journal.”
Emphasizing excellence
For his part, Dr. Nattel says he shapes priorities by emphasizing excellence, and employing intellectual openness and honesty.
An Order of Canada recipient for his contributions to medical research and education, Dr. Nattel hopes the next Editor-in-Chief will continue to improve the journal’s Impact Factor and international reputation. He also wants to see the cardiovascular community take full advantage of the opportunities the journals present.
“They’re a very rich source of development for Canadian academics,” he says. “The journals can provide a first publishing opportunity, experience in reviewing and editing, and a primary place to publish.”
When he started in his role, Dr. Nattel says the job was “reasonably contained”. But,“as the journal became more successful, open-access journals were added, the Impact Factor increased, the number of submissions exploded, and our integration with the CCS increased, it became an all-absorbing exercise.“
Asked what he plans to do after stepping down from CJC, Dr. Nattel laughs and says he’ll “stop working around the clock, and be able to take real vacations.” He will have time to dive more deeply into his scientific interests – atrial fibrillation, cardiac arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology – and spend more time with his wife, four children and 16 grandchildren.
With gratitude and thanks, the cardiovascular community acknowledges this shift in priorities is well deserved.
Other News
See AllThe CCS Celebrates Recent Passing of The Heart Valve Disease Awareness Act (Bill 66)
February 6, 2025
The CCS is proud to highlight the Legislative Assembly of Ontario’s recent passing of The Heart...
CCS News